Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Newsletter Excerpt, November 17, 2026 -- "Mailbag Pt. 2, Business"

This is a preview of the Joe Sheehan Baseball Newsletter, an e-mail newsletter about all things baseball, featuring analysis and opinion about the game on and off the field from the perspective of the informed outsider.

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)

-
 

I'm really worried about the open discussion about a labor lockout being, to borrow a term of art from the industry, fait accompli. 


Before the NHL taking it to an arguably industry-damaging extreme, a lockout was a nuclear option of questionable legality. Now it's just another economic weapon seen as equivalent to a strike. 


But it isn't inevitable. The owners could give up on arbitrary caps on payroll and work on better revenue sharing amongst themselves and wrap it all up before December 1. 28 of the existing teams (Mets and Dodgers excepted, and the Mets are probably not going to be a part of this club for a couple of seasons) already treat the existing luxury tax as something pretty close to a de facto cap, and they didn't even need to bargain a floor to get it. 


-- Nick G.


This is where you have to look at the actual goals. This is entirely about franchise values, which skyrocket if you can get a cap on labor costs. Labor peace, a fair settlement, more revenue sharing…none of those things drive up franchise values the way a cap will. That’s the goal here, and that’s why they’re going to war. Everything else is a smokescreen.


The lockout is designed to force the union to agree to a cap as a path to raising franchise values.


-J.


- 

 

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.) 

Monday, November 16, 2026

Newsletter Excerpt, November 16, 2026 -- "Mailbag Pt. 1, Baseball"

 

This is a preview of the Joe Sheehan Baseball Newsletter, an e-mail newsletter about all things baseball, featuring analysis and opinion about the game on and off the field from the perspective of the informed outsider.

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)

-
 

What changes do you see the Yankees making in the offseason to fix their stagnant offense?  With Jazz Chisholm Jr. leaving as a free agent, will Luis Garcia Jr. become the second baseman to get Giancarlo Stanton's bat back in the lineup? While they steal bases in the regular season that becomes a moot point in the postseason when they revert back to their three true outcomes offense. While the TTO is understandable due to the difficulty scoring in the playoffs it just feels like there needs to be some major changes somewhere.


-- Ed D.


It’s such an incredibly awkward build at the moment. Garcia is unplayable at second, so right now that’s Anthony Volpe, but I could see Brandon Lowe — a pretty good fit for the ballpark — be signed for 3/70 or something. Honestly, I’d just non-tender Garcia, who has no spot on this team now. Lowe may be the only place this team can reasonably spend money this winter. It’s an awful market for hitters and they do not need a big-time starting pitcher. 


I’d release Stanton and eat the $29 million. He has 1700 PA and three WAR over the last five years, is 37, can’t play in the field, yet he consumes enormous amounts of energy as the guy people remember from the 2024 playoff run. He’s an anchor, and the Yankees may need to play Aaron Judge more at DH next year anyway. Stanton’s contract is a sunk cost.


The real problem is the homegrown guys who stalled out or never launched. Austin Wells is dropping 15 points of OPS+ a year. They’ve simply buried Volpe and Jasson Dominguez, letting one play through an injury in 2025 and playing the other out of position for three years. Dominguez is two years younger than Spencer Jones, just two years older than George Lombard Jr., and I think he’s better than both. I badly want to see Dominguez left alone in center field for six months. I’m also not sold on Lombard just yet; I think he was rushed up and should spend half a year back at Triple-A. I also think if you’re going to play him and Volpe, Volpe needs to be the shortstop.


So let’s see…if it’s just me making the decisions...


1B Rice

RF Judge

LF Bellinger

2B Lowe

CF Dominguez

DH Jones

3B McMahon/Caballero

SS Volpe

C Wells


Heliot Ramos, the other third baseman, a backup catcher who can hit, and a free agent make up the bench. That last guy may need to be a right-handed-hitting outfielder who can play center. Myles Straw, Tyrone Taylor, that kind of guy. Stanton released, Garcia non-tendered, Lombard in the minors. 


I should probably just do a whole Yankees Newsletter.


-J.


- 

 

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.) 

Newsletter Excerpt, November 14, 2026 -- "Aging Swerve"

This is a preview of the Joe Sheehan Baseball Newsletter, an e-mail newsletter about all things baseball, featuring analysis and opinion about the game on and off the field from the perspective of the informed outsider.

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)

-
 

There’s a conflict that grows a bit more fierce each offseason. We want teams to invest money in payroll to get better, and we excoriate owners who won’t do their part to try to win. Each year, though, the free-agent market seems to grow a bit less attractive. I have a very hard time saying the Reds or the Pirates or the Marlins should put a four-year deal in front of the hitters on this year’s market, because everything I know about the modern game tells me there’s little chance for a strong return on that investment. In all of Major League Baseball last year, there were six players 33 and older who put up three-win seasons. Think that’s too high a standard? Make it two wins, a bang-average player, and you find 13, more than half of whom are going to find themselves either in the Hall of Fame or in midst of debates about their candidacy. 


- 

 

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.) 

Newsletter Excerpt, November 12, 2026 -- "The Old College Why?"

 

This is a preview of the Joe Sheehan Baseball Newsletter, an e-mail newsletter about all things baseball, featuring analysis and opinion about the game on and off the field from the perspective of the informed outsider.

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)

-
 

I cannot think of a worse model for an MLB manager than “SEC football coach.” Vitello is correct: a two-game losing streak by the football team at Alabama or Georgia or Tennessee creates a crisis atmosphere in a sport where two losses can often eliminate you from championship consideration. Well, for one more season, anyway. A two-game losing streak in baseball is nothing. It’s a blink. Teams can lose two games in 18 hours, two games in six hours. 


If Vitello, after spending a full season as an MLB manager, feels he needs to turn to SEC football to learn how to manage losing, that, to me, is disqualifying. The Brewers lost 59 times this year, including six in a row at one point. They had 13 losing streaks of at least two games. The Rays lost 64 times, topping out at five in a row. These were the most successful teams in baseball, one a champion, one a pennant winner. The fundamental truth of baseball is that losing is baked into the cake. The best teams in baseball are going to lose twice a week no matter how good they are. 


- 

 

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.) 

 

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Joe Sheehan Newsletter, November 10, 2026 -- "Lock Out the Lockout"

 

This is a preview of the Joe Sheehan Baseball Newsletter, an e-mail newsletter about all things baseball, featuring analysis and opinion about the game on and off the field from the perspective of the informed outsider.

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)

-
 

The Joe Sheehan Newsletter: Lock Out the Lockout

Vol. 18, No. 98

November 10, 2026


We’re three weeks away from the expiration of the 2022-26 Collective Bargaining Agreement. That document was signed after a 99-day owners’ lockout that delayed and shortened spring training and delayed the start of the season. In the end, the current CBA left the prior CBA in place with some changes around the margins. We got a pay-for-performance scheme for young players, the expansion of the postseason, a draft lottery, and an agreement that MLB could change gameplay rules without players’ approval. The larger structures built up around revenue and player compensation stayed the same -- split-pool revenue sharing, six-year free agency, significant penalties for spending past a certain point on players. 


The owners’ representative, Rob Manfred -- surely we can leave behind any illusions about the “commissioner” title -- took from that process that an offseason lockout is a good thing. As he told Evan Drellich in 2025, “In a bizarre way, it’s actually a positive. There is leverage associated with an offseason lockout and the process of collective bargaining under the [National Labor Relations Act] works based on leverage. The great thing about offseason lockouts is the leverage that exists gets applied [equally] between the bargaining parties.”


This isn’t true. The players don’t get paid in the offseason, while owners bring in revenue from payments on season-ticket renewals. MLB’s TV partners usually continue paying the league during a lockout, though MLB may have to repay the networks if games are missed. The owners also are more likely to receive non-baseball income. Many players are unemployed during the offseason, and a lockout means they can’t find new employers. Players are also cut off from team doctors whose care they may need as they recover from injuries suffered during the season. Lockouts are designed to leverage those pressure points to force labor into an agreement. 


Manfred knows this, of course. From the Drellich piece:


Manfred drew a distinction. Compared to an in-season work stoppage, he said the offseason variety is “like using a .22 (caliber firearm), as opposed to a shotgun or a nuclear weapon.”


Once you’re comparing labor tactics to weaponry, specifics don’t matter. You’ve declared war.


Throughout this year, Manfred has seemed eager to pull his .22, sounding gleeful at times about the pending lockout. He knows the league won the last round of bargaining by using a lockout. Manfred knows the players, in the end, approved the current CBA over the objections of its executive committee. He knows the teams are five years better at exploiting the holes in the current compensation structure, knows life for mid-tier baseball players is, because of that exploitation, even worse. MLB does not need to tie necessary CBA changes to a payroll cap, but by doing so, MLB may achieve the owners’ Holy Grail: a legal agreement to limit competition for labor. Manfred, in his role as the owners’ chief negotiator, is positioned to press his perceived advantage.


Against that backdrop, then, MLB’s latest offer to the players is interesting. Oh, it still involves a payroll cap, and as I have said many times, as long as that is the case, there is no middle ground on which to meet. A cap is binary; either there is one or there isn’t. The two sides aren’t on the same axis right now, so there isn’t much for them to negotiate. 


Within that offer, though, may have been an off-ramp. MLB is proposing that an agreed-upon cap system be delayed until 2028, with the 2027 season played under the current rule set. Revenue sharing and the payroll-tax system would stay in place through next season. This may be less a concession to the players than to reality. Unlike in all negotiations since 1994, MLB is proposing a radical change to the entire compensation structure, and to do that in one offseason -- in fact, in just part of one offseason -- would be impossible. MLB’s latest offer included a payroll minimum of $180 million, and it’s not realistic to expect teams at the bottom of the scale to reach that figure in one offseason. There’s not enough talent in the market or on their own rosters. 


Once you’ve conceded that 2027 can be played under the same rules as 2026, you’ve removed much of the need for a lockout this winter. Oh, there are other changes that might be negotiated into the next CBA and take effect immediately, but the main issue here is payroll cap or not. That’s a fight that now doesn’t have to be resolved this winter. Remember, a lockout is voluntary; as was the case in 1994, baseball can continue under the terms of the current CBA until a new one is agreed upon.


It’s not entirely that simple. There’s a sunset clause in the current CBA, a poison pill of sorts, that reads, “There shall be no Competitive Balance Tax in place following the 2026 championship season.” Obviously, most owners will not want to play the 2027 season allowing high-payroll teams a freeroll. That is something that can be negotiated, however. Think of it as the baseball version of a continuing resolution. To get to a CR, both sides have to want it. At last month’s World Series, both Manfred and MLPBA leader Bruce Meyer seemed to reject the notion.


That 1994 dispute ended in a players’ strike in August, one that led to the cancellation of the World Series. The players, at the time, sensed the owners would lock them out in the offseason and implement a cap system. The players struck to prevent that from happening, and in the hopes a deal would be reached in time for the playoffs. That did not happen, of course, and the sequence served to illustrate the gap in leverage each side has. If the owners agree to not lock out the players this winter, they may want a no-strike/no-lockout agreement that covers the 2027 season. Now, most unions will never concede their right to strike. Given I don’t think the current MLBPA can hold a successful strike, and may not even vote to approve a walkout, a no-strike/no-lockout agreement that covers ’27 may be their best path through this.


Owners want a new CBA sooner rather than later so they can get on with negotiating new national-TV deals from a position of labor peace. The current suite of deals all expire after the 2028 season. That still leaves a lot of time to get to a new CBA over the next year without a lockout and negotiate those new deals. MLB is eager to divide its 2430 games into 243 small packages requiring you to pay $9.95 a month to watch three games on each one. (The position MLB has taken, that it’s pursuing a payroll cap because it’s what the fans want, is laughable when set against the current and future baseball media landscape, which is as anti-consumer as you could design.)


This MLB proposal is the first step towards buying time, time both sides need, time that may be enough for them to avoid the kind of spiral from which there is no recovery. MLB wants new TV deals, wants new teams, wants new ballparks, wants cities and states fighting to cough up billions, wants fans signing up for AppleFlix Premium+ to watch two exclusive games a month. The path to all those things does not run through a fractured season that alienates everyone who might be lining up with open wallets. I say again that this isn’t 1994. Few of the elements that existed then, ones that helped the game get off the mat following a canceled World Series, exist today. 


There is no crisis that mandates a change in the rules. Most teams are making money, with the league as a whole up to $12 billion in revenue. Sale prices for teams continue to rise. Competitive balance is good. To the extent MLB has problems, they’re more about the game on the field than off of it. Another year under the current CBA rules, with agreements to modify the sunset clause and perhaps a no-strike/no-lockout agreement, wouldn’t hurt anyone.


This all kicks the can down the road, but face it, this is a can that looks much better down the road. With MLB acknowledging that a cap can’t be put into effect in one offseason, they should withdraw their lockout threat and work out a deal with the MLBPA to continue under the current CBA for one more year.


- 

 

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.) 

 

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Newsletter Excerpt, November 4, 2026 -- "A Very Simple War"

This is a preview of the Joe Sheehan Baseball Newsletter, an e-mail newsletter about all things baseball, featuring analysis and opinion about the game on and off the field from the perspective of the informed outsider.

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)

-
 

It’s a single-issue negotiation. MLB wants a cap, the players reject a cap. All of the details MLB has shared about its vision -- a number of which are good! -- are tied to the MLBPA accepting a cap system. Publicly, at least, the league has not put forth any vision of a non-capped league. The players, and again I’ll say this is based on what we know, appear to have no intention of accepting a payroll cap. 


Until one side or the other concedes on this point, there is nowhere for negotiations to go. These aren’t two sides at opposite ends of a conference table with a path towards meeting in the middle. There is no middle ground between “cap” and “no cap.” You can’t calculate the average of an orange and a orangutan. 


- 

 

You can subscribe to the newsletter for one year for $89.95 using your PayPal account or major credit card. (Zelle users, please email me for details.)